Will GOP Moderates Fail their Principles and the People?

In the past I’ve been a supporter of the moderate element in the Republican Party. I even blog occasionally for the Republican Leadership Council. They’re the heirs of Abraham Lincoln and Teddy Roosevelt and their socially liberal and fiscally conservative positions are at the heart of Republican tradition. I lean more libertarian, but I’ve always seen Republican moderates as natural allies with a lot in common with the libertarian wing of the party.

In the past when there has been disagreement between moderate Republicans and the more ideologically extreme wings of the party, the main thing which has redeemed the moderates in the eyes of doubters and justified party unity is that they have remembered the importance of fiscal responsibility, an essential Republican value which some other factions within the party seem to have lost track of in recent years.

But now, faced with an unprecedented economic crisis and a Democrat-dominated Congress running out of control, it looks like some of the moderates in the GOP are going to fail the party and fail the country by supporting the ill-conceived “stimulus” bill in some sort of misguided fit of irrational bipartisanship. The latest news reports suggest that Senators Arlen Specter (R-PA), Olympia Snowe (R-ME) and Susan Collins (R-ME) may vote with the Democrats to give them the 60 votes they need in the Senate to pass this massive spending package. Collins argues that their cooperation is justified because of $110 billion in cuts which have brought the cost of the Senate version of the bill back down to about the $800 billion total of the House version.

The problem is that despite the name which has been attached to it in an effort to provide positive spin, this is anything but a “stimulus” bill. The bill creates far fewer jobs than has been claimed, at a ridiculous cost of hundreds of thousands of dollars per possible job, and most of those jobs are short-term with no lasting positive impact. The tax cuts it contains are misdirected and will have very limited stimulus value. There’s still a great deal of pork and earmarked spending on pet projects. But that’s really all beside the point. We’re in the middle of a fiscal crisis which was to a large extent precipitated by overspending and overextension of credit, not just by the big banks but by the federal government. To spend almost a trillion dollars which the government does not have does nothing but compound the fiscal irresponsibility which created the crisis in the first place. It will further devalue the dollar, increase inflation and likely create more business failures and greater unemployment.

Last week Douglas Elmendorf, Director of the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office, made observations on the likely effects of the bill. He suggests that the beneficial effects of the bill will wear off quickly after about two years, and that the long term effect will be a reduction in available capital and ultimately a long-term reduction in GDP of between .1 and .3 percent. Elmendorf’s concerns are mild compared to those of prominent economists on both the political left and right who are increasingly unified in opposition to the bill. Over 200 of them took out an ad opposing it in the New York Times, saying that:

“It is a triumph of hope over experience to believe that more government spending will help the U.S. today. To improve the economy, policy makers should focus on reforms that remove impediments to work, saving, investment and production. Lower tax rates and a reduction in the burden of government are the best ways of using fiscal policy to boost growth.”

Relatively moderate Harvard economist Martin Feldstein who had initially supported the bill came out unequivocally against it in an editorial where he calls it “An $800 Billion Mistake” and specifically faults it for gross deficit spending with too little stimulus. In an article in the Wall Street Journal economists Alberto Alesina and Luigi Zingales sum up the problem with the bill succinctly: “Tax cuts have a much better effect on job creation than highway rehabilitation.”

Given all of this it would be a terrible mistake for Republican moderates to adopt a misguided “go along to get along” attitude and vote with the Democrats when standing firm on their belief in fiscal responsibility might be just what’s needed to find a better solution. It’s quite likely that doing nothing at all would be better than this bill. But at the very least, Republicans in the Senate ought to hold out for a bill which has less unnecessary spending and more genuine stimulus in the form of tax cuts for individuals and businesses.

I’ve always believed that moderate Republicans had remarkably good sense and the best interests of the people at heart. Like many others in the party I’ve put my trust in them over the years to balance out the voices of extremism because they could be counted on when it eally mattered. But if these three are going to betray the fiscally responsible traditions of the GOP and vote to support this disastrous bill, then they have clearly lost their way and will have failed as Republicans and as stewards of the best interests of their constituents and the nation.

You may want to contact these Senators and encourage them to develop some spine and remember their values. You can email them with these links: Specter, Snowe, Collins. These are alternate links because their Senate contact pages are being crashed by the volume of emails.


About Dave 534 Articles
Dave Nalle has worked as a magazine editor, a freelance writer, a capitol hill staffer, a game designer and taught college history for many years. He now designs fonts for a living and lives with his family in a small town just outside Austin where he is ex-president of the local Lions Club. He is on the board of the Republican Liberty Caucus and Politics Editor of Blogcritics Magazine. You can find his writings about fonts, art and graphic design at The Scriptorium. He also runs a conspiracy debunking site at IdiotWars.com.


  1. I feel it may be the time for REAL CHANGE, maybe we need to take a page from the Liberal’s, and get a voice of our own.

    The cure is instead of crying in your beer, or milk.

    Stand up and get mad, get on the phones, get the e-mails fired up, and tell these fools, the jig is up.

    Get a hold of your freinds and neighbors, and get them fired up. It’s our country, we have to fight for it. It is still the best thing around,but not for long if we do not get with the program.

    We will only have ourselves to blame.

    This link will allow you too monitor how your senator’s vote on bills.


    These links will get you access to your senator’s and you representative’s in the house.



    Please take an afternoon, turn off the TV, radio, get on line and tell these fools, you are going to hold them accountable, for the trashing of this once great country.

    If you do not have a lot of time for this effort, at least get Polosis the speaker of the house, and Harry Reid, leader in the senate. Bare minimum, blast them with e-mails and phone calls.



    Please if you do not have time, share this information with others who do. Thanks, do not let them fool you anymore.

  2. Be aware that as noted in the article the regular links Robert posts for emailing your Senators and Congressmen may be completely swamped. They’re getting incredible numbers of calls and the calls are running 100 to 1 or more against the stimulus package. But apparently they don’t much care.


  3. It is time for state sovereignty. We have to stand up. The federal government is taxing the people with this “three legged stool”, then they are putting unfunded mandates on the states, who in turn pass the cost down to the people! WE THE PEOPLE ARE FED UP! Our houses are worthless, but we have to pay just as much taxes and insurance on them as we did before. Our insurance coverage has gone down, but the cost has gone up. The feds. are printing money so fast that a role of toilet paper is worth more than the dollar. The government has borrowed so much money from China and others that if they call in the loan, which we cannot pay, they will own the US! What else has to happen before we do something?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.