The Human Cost of Rationing Healthcare

This week the Congressional Budget Office projected enormous cost increases under the current congressional plan for national health care. It was promoted as saving taxpayers money, but the CBO estimates a cost over $1 trillion and it is likely to raise the tax burden for many Americans to close to 60% of their already dwindling incomes, as government bureaucrats balloon the cost of what is already the most expensive health care system in the world. The devastating financial impact of ObamaCare for the nation and every citizen is now overwhelmingly clear. But just in case you still harbor any illusions about how disastrous current proposals for national health care would be, I thought it was time to revisit the other cost — the cost in human suffering and loss of life under socialized medicine.

A key element of the cynically misnamed Affordable Health Choices Act, which is the plan currently being rushed through congress to meet deadlines and criteria set by President Obama, is rationing health care using Comparative Effectiveness Research (CER) methodology where government bureaucrats would set up schedules by which treatment would be allocated based on statistics and cost to benefit ratios rather than the interests and needs of the specific patient. Decisions on care would be matters of policy based on group effectiveness rather than on a case by case basis and doctors would have to abide by these decisions without regard to the welfare of the patient.

The impact of rationing in other nations where it has been introduced as part of the national health care system has been horrendous. It attempts to reduce the financial cost of the system by a trade-off which increases the cost in lives lost and individual suffering. Two nations with many similarities to the United States which have resorted to rationing health care are Great Britain and Canada. In both nations the human cost has been high and the results are easily quantified.

The failure of rationing comes down to two basic problems — denial of treatment and very long wait times. Both of these can result in suffering and death for patients, especially those with critical and chronic conditions which are treated easily and routinely in the United States today, but which often result in death in Great Britain and Canada.

One telling scenario of denial of care comes with cardiac patients. In the United States if you come into a hospital with an arterial blockage you are usually scheduled for an angioplasty or a bypass in a matter of days, because that is the best way to achieve a long-term solution to the problem. In Canada and Britain the common response is dictated by a shortage of surgeons and facilities, so you are given beta blockers to try to keep your heart functioning and sent away. If you're lucky you'll survive the months that it takes to get you scheduled for surgery or maybe come into the hospital in the middle of an actual heart attack when your chances of surviving the surgery are lower but they may actually operate. Or even better, if you live in Canada they may slap on a heart monitor and have an ambulance drive you to the US for treatment as they do with hundreds of cardiac patients every year. The sad reality is that many who are denied immediate surgical treatment for heart problems just die.

In the US a coronary patient is four times as likely to receive surgical treatment as in Britain. In the US only 5% of Americans are made to wait more than four months for surgery. In Canada 27% wait four months or more and in Britain 36% wait four months or more. While the base rate of coronary disease in the US is higher than in other countries because of diet and lifestyle, the rate of survival for those diagnosed with coronary problems is much higher than in other countries because patients get the best and most appropriate treatment more quickly.

The same pattern holds true with cancer. Overall Britons and Europeans in general die at a higher rate from all forms of cancer than US citizens and the difference is dramatic in cases where early detection and treatment are important. For example, women with breast cancer in Britain have a 46% death rate as opposed to 25% in the US. Men with prostate cancer in Britain have a 57% mortality rate while in the US only 19% die and the death rate is declining rapidly because of early detection. It's the same with colon cancer. In Europe as a whole there is only a 8% survival rate, in Britain there's a 40% survival rate and in the US there's a 60% survival rate. With cancer of the esophagus only 7% survive while in the US 12% survive, although it's still one of the most deadly forms of cancer. Both long- and short-term recovery and survival rates for all forms of cancer are also significantly higher for US patients. Rationed care has limited diagnostic facilities like MRI machines and has created long wait times for specialist doctors. In fact, 40% of cancer patients in Britain never get to see a cancer specialist at all, and the National Health bureaucrats have denied basic tests like pap smears and ruled out powerful chemotherapy medicines as too expensive, all of which has cost lives. With diseases like cancer where early detection and treatment are vital,  resource rationing means a lot more dead patients.

The human cost of delay of care caused by rationing is particularly significant. One key element of this is the wait time to see a specialist who can provide the best treatment for specific ailments. In the US 74% of patients get to see a specialist within four weeks. In Canada only 40% get seen that quickly and in Britain only 42%. In many cases these delays can cost lives, but the cost of suffering has to be considered as well. In both Canada and Britain the wait times are even longer for conditions which are not life threatening, but can be very painful and seriously reduce quality of life. In Britain a hip or knee replacement can take more than five months and in Canada it can take as long as eight months. That's a very long time when pain is literally crippling.

An unsurprising irony is that as our congress looks at health care reform, activists in Canada, Britain, and a number of other countries are also looking at health care reform. The difference is that they are trying to figure out ways to introduce more choice and more market elements and reduce rationing at the same time we are plunging headlong into the same mistakes which they made a generation ago and which they now realize have left them with unacceptable failures in their systems with thousands of preventable deaths every year and millions stuck on waiting lists for essential treatment.

This is how bad it can get with government-run, single-payer systems, which may have a cost in lives and suffering, but do at least bring down the cost of health care. Imagine how much worse it could be with a combination of government bureaucracy and rationing and the high prices of private insurance and you have some idea of what ObamaCare will be like. It is likely to have all the flaws of socialized medicine while preserving most of the shortcomings of our current private insurance system, because the thousand-page bill which congress was considering is largely authored by lobbyists for the health care, pharmaceutical and insurance industries. It's like yet another bailout for these industries at a high cost in life, suffering and taxation to the American people.

Even the far left agrees that the health care plan currently being rammed through congress serves the interests of big insurance, medical and pharmaceutical companies while doing more harm than good to the average citizen. It rations and reduces the quality of medical care. It massively increases costs and forces small businesses and individuals to purchase insurance plans at inflated prices which they cannot afford or pay substantial penalties which they also can't afford. It passes many of these costs on to the public in huge tax increases. It doesn't solve the key problem of inflated insurance and health care costs and is projected to still leave 20 million people uninsured.

This may be the most monumental legislative disaster ever given serious consideration in the notoriously profligate halls of congress. This plan is not what the American people have in mind when they think of health care reform. It ignores their needs and sets their interests aside to pander to statist radicals and big business. The American people deserve better.

Digg!

About Dave 534 Articles
Dave Nalle has worked as a magazine editor, a freelance writer, a capitol hill staffer, a game designer and taught college history for many years. He now designs fonts for a living and lives with his family in a small town just outside Austin where he is ex-president of the local Lions Club. He is on the board of the Republican Liberty Caucus and Politics Editor of Blogcritics Magazine. You can find his writings about fonts, art and graphic design at The Scriptorium. He also runs a conspiracy debunking site at IdiotWars.com.

46 Comments

  1. One thing I would like to say is car insurance cancelling is a dreadful experience and if you are doing the correct things as being a driver you’ll not get one. Lots of people do obtain notice that they’ve been officially dropped by the insurance company they have to struggle to get added insurance from a cancellation. Low-priced auto insurance rates usually are hard to get after having a cancellation. Knowing the main reasons concerning the auto insurance cancellation can help owners prevent losing one of the most critical privileges accessible. Thanks for the strategies shared through your blog.

  2. Bankruptcy isn’t as bad as people People are too worried about I know many folks who have filed for bankruptcy only a couple years ago and am doing You only need credit if you’re trying to borrow You SHOULD NOT Be borrowing money anymore in the first Just save money in the You don’t need credit when you got CASH HOMIE! Haha

  3. Hi, Neat post. There’s a problem along with your website in web explorer,
    would test this? IE still is the marketplace chief and a large portion of folks will pass over your
    great writing because of this problem.

  4. This article pгesents cⅼear idea designed forr tɦe new visitors of
    blogging, that іn fact hhow to Ԁο running a blog.

    Hеre iѕ mʏ web blog :: skylerebvn665drainfieldsblog.fսll-design.сom
    (Minnie)

  5. Greаt site. Lots of useful info Һere. Ⅰ am sending it tⲟ
    some buddies ans also sharing in delicious. Ꭺnd cеrtainly,
    thankѕ on yoսr effort!

    Heгe iѕ mʏ blog … beauongh739blog.affiliatblogger.com
    Samira,

  6. I’m гeally impressed аlong աith youjr writing taents aand аlso ѡith the foormat on youг blog.
    Is tҺis a paid subject oг did yⲟu modify іt your self?

    Eiither waay кeep սp the excellent quqlity writing, іt’s rare to see a nice blog liҝe tһis one tһeѕe daуs..

    Also vosit mmy web pagе; joaquinjzpp047blog.blogminds.ϲom – Carmon

  7. Hey There. I found your weblog using msn. This is a really neatly written article.
    I will be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your helpful information. Thank you for the post.
    I will certainly comeback.

  8. Have you ever thought about including a little bit more than just your articles?
    I mean, what you say is fundamental and everything.
    But think of if you added some great images or video clips to give your posts more, “pop”!
    Your content is excellent but with pics and videos, this website could certainly be one
    of the best in its niche. Awesome blog!

  9. Currently it sounds like Expression Engine is the preferred blogging platform available right now. (from what Ive read) Is that what youre using on your blog?

  10. Биографии писателей для первоклассников
    школ для изготовления домашних уроков вы отыщите на данном сайте
    http://sochrulit.ru/ и вместе с ними сумеете выполнить правильно задачу.

    Сочинения по русскому языку помогут получить хорошую оценку и
    окажут помощь отлично закончить четверть.

  11. Herzlich willkommen zu unserem geilen Erotik, Sex und Porno Blog – mit heissen angeboten wie Amateur Livesex gratis vor der Webcam, private Sex Bilder geile Frauen und heissen Boy Stuten im Sex Chat zum anschauen.

  12. Hi, i believe that i noticed you visited my website thus i came
    to return the want?.I am trying to to find things to improve my website!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!!

  13. Wonderful goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous
    to and you’re just extremely great. I really like what you’ve acquired here,
    really like what you’re stating and the way in which
    you say it. You make it entertaining and you still take care of to keep
    it smart. I can’t wait to read far more from you.
    This is really a great website.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*