Nativism is Not Republican, Conservative or Libertarian

I often find myself bewildered when I encounter people who claim to be libertarians or conservatives who have taken a nativist stand on immigration. Typically I encounter this in people from the far right of the Republican Party or from supporters of Ron Paul and in the context of the presidential candidacy of John McCain. They usually come up with a statement which starts “I could vote for McCain, but…” and follow with the unforgivable crime which McCain has committed. Over half the time that crime is his endorsement of ‘amnesty’ for illegal aliens in the failed 2007 immigration reform bill. That’s when I start scratching my head and wondering what kind of brainworms these self-proclaimed conservatives and libertarians are infested with. Putting aside the fact that the immigration bill contained no measures which more than vaguely resembled amnesty, what mystifies me is how they can call themselves conservatives or libertarians and still hold a nativist position on immigration.

For a start, the nativist anti-immigration position has always been a policy of the political left, from northeastern Democrats with a racist fear of ‘foreign wretches’ to pro-labor socialists who see immigration as a threat to the welfare of American workers. Nativism makes some sense for the political left. It goes hand in hand with their protectionist stand on labor and industry. It makes no sense at all for a right wing which is supposed to be capitalist and pro-business, in favor of free trade, free labor and keeping wages and inflation low.

Republican Immigration Policy

From its very start the Republican Party has been pro-immigration and the fact that some Republican politicians like Tom Tancredo and Duncan Hunter are now building their careers on an exclusionary policy on immigration is a sign of how far the party has strayed from its roots. One of the cornerstones of the party when it was founded was the idea of ‘free labor’, applying both to slaves and immigrants. The party platform of 1860 said that the party “is opposed to any change in our Naturalization Laws or any State legislation by which the rights of our citizenship hitherto accorded to immigrants from foreign lands shall be abridged or impaired; and in favor of giving a full and efficient protection to the rights of all classes of citizens, whether native or naturalized, both at home and abroad.” That’s an extremely liberal position on immigration, suggesting that the rights of citizenship in the United States are inherent to anyone in the world.

Admittedly, the GOP has become more conservative since the time of Lincoln, but along with that it has also become even more the party of business and industry, and from that perspective a relatively open and liberal immigration policy also makes a lot of sense. Businesses need workers and they always want to cut their overhead. Letting in low-wage workers from overseas or south of the border benefits business, keeps wages down and keeps prices reasonable and US products more competitive in an international market where wages are generally much lower than they are in the US. It’s the more desirable flip-side of outsourcing. Bringing the cheap labor here instead of sending our industries overseas seems like a pretty good idea if we want to compete internationally. That’s a priority of business and it has always been a priority for the Republican Party.

Conservative Immigration Policy

The one thing which the current generation of conservative leaders can always seem to agree on is that Ronald Reagan was a great president and the father of the modern conservative movement. Yet in the next breath they’re likely to condemn liberal immigration policies and damn John McCain for his supposed amnesty bill. What they seem to have conveniently forgotten is that Reagan was as big on open immigration as any other pro-business traditional Republican and supported and signed off on the one true immigration amnesty bill of the modern era.

In 1986 Reagan gave unconditional amnesty to over 3 million illegals living in the United States, no questions asked. They just had to sign up and they could become citizens. Reagan’s was a real amnesty bill, nothing like the very moderate immigration reform which was considered last year and included serious penalties for illegals wishing to attain a legal status. Reagan’s bill was supported by most Republicans in Congress and passed easily, yet despite this he remains a figure of legendary status among conservatives.

In that era being a bit soft on illegal immigration was seen as a positive because it was perceived as a good thing for the economy, keeping wages and inflation down, helping out businesses and even adding willing workers to the workforce. Back then the GOP remembered that it was a party based at least in part on supporting business and positive economic policies. The focus was on the economic benefits of immigration and socially conservative fear of foreign infiltration was laughed at by anyone sensible.

Reagan’s reasonable view of immigration seems to have been forgotten and this new nativist trend is a divergence from the long-term stance of the party and it’s not a change for the better. It’s not the way the party would have acted even a few years ago and it really doesn’t make any sense today either.

What troubles me about this is that 10 years ago no conservative politician would have seriously tried to build a campaign or a career on a nativist stance on immigration the way that people like Tancredo have done, and there certainly wouldn’t have been a widespread movement to close the borders and someone like McCain wouldn’t be reviled by any significant number of Republicans for taking a moderate stance on immigration.

Libertarian Immigration Policy

Even weirder is the recent trend among libertarians, both in the Libertarian Party and among the libertarian element of the GOP, to take a nativist stance against immigration. This viewpoint seems to be spearheaded by Ron Paul and his followers who have borrowed a lot of the plays in their book from the John Birch Society.

Historically the libertarian position on immigration has been to favor absolutely open borders. That’s not just liberal immigration policy, that’s letting people stroll over and live here without even asking them any questions or keeping any track of them. Libertarians believe in freedom and that freedom is universal. Everyone has a right to be free, not just those lucky enough to live in the United States. Freedom includes freedom of movement and the right to choose where you live. The logical conclusion of that for most Libertarians has been to have wide open borders, at least until recently.

In fact, for 30 years, every Libertarian Party platform included in its section on immigration this unequivocal concluding phrase or something very much like it:

“We therefore call for the elimination of all restrictions on immigration, the abolition of the Immigration and Naturalization Service and the Border Patrol, and a declaration of full amnesty for all people who have entered the country illegally.”

While this changed gradually to a much more conservative stand on immigration starting in 2002, it’s quite clear what the beliefs of the party were for most of its history, beliefs which were shared by founders like Murray Rothbard. Even when I talked to current Libertarian Presidential candidate Bob Barr last week, he took a relatively moderate stand on immigration, acknowledging the need for foreign workers and a dynamic labor force, but stressing that open borders were no longer party policy.

As a party the Libertarians still have the most open position on immigration, yet these days you’ll be hard pressed to find a libertarian in the Ron Paul faction or a libertarian Republican who will openly acknowledge that the nation’s prosperity is built on the basis of cheap immigrant labor and that we need that labor for that prosperity to continue.

The Folly of Nativism

Today the resurgent nativist movement is being driven by demagogues like Lou Dobbs, Pat Buchanan, Jerome Corsi and Alex Jones and groups like the Minute Men and the John Birch Society. It is a movement of the radical fringe which has come to infect the mainstream political agenda of the Republican Party, despite the fact that it is against the traditions of the party and the best interests of their constituency.

Republicans usually decry the high cost of doing business and revile the segment of the population which would rather take welfare than work. Immigrants are willing to work at lower wages and do the jobs which so many native born workers aren’t interested in. They are the answer to every capitalists dream, bringing down wages, prices and business overhead, and increasing productivity. And the truth is that they really aren’t competing for jobs with most of the native population. Whenever there’s a regional crackdown on illegals you see certain sectors of the economy grind to a halt because of the shortage of labor.

If you are a Republican of the Conservative or Libertarian variety like so many in the more activist wing of the party, supporting harsh immigration restrictions just makes no sense. It doesn’t fit with the rest of your ideology or the history and traditions of the party and the people promoting it most ardently like Lou Dobbs and Pat Buchanan come from a populist or even socialist tradition which would be more compatible with the modern Democratic Party than with any reasonable position on the right where capitalism and prosperity are valued. Immigrant labor is a key element of a strong economy. If you oppose immigration you might want to think about where the labor needed to drive economic growth is going to come from instead.

Digg!

About Dave 536 Articles
Dave Nalle has worked as a magazine editor, a freelance writer, a capitol hill staffer, a game designer and taught college history for many years. He now designs fonts for a living and lives with his family in a small town just outside Austin where he is ex-president of the local Lions Club. He is on the board of the Republican Liberty Caucus and Politics Editor of Blogcritics Magazine. You can find his writings about fonts, art and graphic design at The Scriptorium. He also runs a conspiracy debunking site at IdiotWars.com.

6 Comments

  1. [url=http://orlandiefranzosiadvocacia.com/index.php/noticias/item/41-aplicativos-gratuitos-do-tse-vao-mostrar-onde-votar-e-informar-resultado/41-aplicativos-gratuitos-do-tse-vao-mostrar-onde-votar-e-informar-resultado?start=60]orlandiefranzosiadvocacia[/url], [url=http://www.quickbeforeitmelts.ca/reviews/qbim-spins/mocky-key-change/]quickbeforeitmelts[/url], [url=http://kijoge.blog.fc2.com/blog-entry-7265.html]kijoge[/url], [url=http://ugandanforum.com/index.php?topic=5020.0]ugandanforum[/url], [url=http://jerrystory.com/UserProfile/tabid/57/userId/494006/Default.aspx]jerrystory[/url], [url=http://campuscrimes.tv/members/ludiep5496999/]campuscrimes[/url],

  2. I’m now not certain the place you are getting your info, however goodtopic. I needs to spend some time finding out more or figuringout more. Thank you for great info I was looking for this infofor my mission.

  3. Did you know these truths on CBD OIL and Full Spectrum CBD Hemp Oil? Cannabinoids are isolated from hemp utilizing supercritical CO2 extraction. Thanks to contemporary innovation, the resulting option is clean, devoid of heavy metals and unneeded waxes, naturally present in the plant, and the drawn liquid has a typical, oily consistency. CBD oil includes cannabidiol as a base component and may include only trace amounts of tetrahydroxycannabidiol (THC). It is suggested by doctors and pharmacists as an antioxidant and substance that blocks the action of proinflammatory cytokines (proteins), e.g. in Crohn’s illness or ulcerative intestinal tract. RSO oil has a low CBD material, while high THC. Of course, the essential task of RSO is to cause a psychoactive effect, although it can also promote “sick” brain structures. It deserves understanding that supplements of this type is mostly utilized by individuals to whom standard therapy does not bring relief in illness. The synergistic (enhancing) action of CBD and THC relative to each other is utilized here. Both cannabinoids can do much more together than when used separately. In addition, they jointly stimulate the division of non-active nerve cells, nourish the fatty envelope of the nerves, and prevent myelin swelling that causes loss of function in some autoimmune illness. There are likewise stories where cannabis in its natural kind softened spasticity, lowered the frequency of convulsions and seizures, and reduced unpleasant scrapie in Parkinson’s disease. This is where the concept of getting RSO, meant just for chronically ill individuals, originated . Both cannabis oil type CBD and RSO also contain other cannabinoids, such as cannabichromene (CBC) and cannabigerol (CBG). The secret is not, however, that CBD frequently has a composition broadened to consist of flavones, flavonoids, terpenes, terpenoids, amino acids and omega acids. The distinction is mainly due to intentions guiding humankind to use one or the other product. CBD medical marijuana oil is a rather helpful mix of cannabinoids, created to protect versus 21st century illness. It’s finest to utilize all of these compounds together, as nature produced them and enclosed in cannabis inflorescences. Oil of marijuana in a kind of pastime APR includes little quantities of CBD, balanced by the presence of THC. – Modern clinical research reveals that CBD + THC cope with serious autoimmune diseases, while CBC or CBG show minimal activity in the existence of both substances, just like terpenes, flavonoids or flavones, therefore their material in the option appears to be unnecessary. In addition, the marijuana pressure from which THC and CBD are derived contain negligible amounts of other cannabinoids. Marijuana oil has currently marked a brand-new age in which male stopped to fear what is unknown, and began to find what our forefathers had currently observed and utilize the substantial potential, in the beginning look, a little unusual relationships, associated generally with pathology. Medical cannabis, contrary to its name, does not imply fermented female inflorescences and leaves including psychoactive substances coiled in so-called “Joints”, but an advantageous oil without psychoactive THC. A basic individual, after taking dosages of medical cannabis and achieving the suitable state of cannabinoids in the blood, can take pleasure in increased resistance, reduced susceptibility to cancer, delayed aging and lowered danger of stroke or heart attack. CBD oil consists of cannabidiol as a base active ingredient and may consist of just trace quantities of tetrahydroxycannabidiol (THC). RSO oil has a low CBD content, while high THC. Both cannabis oil type CBD and RSO also consist of other cannabinoids, such as cannabichromene (CBC) and cannabigerol (CBG). CBD medical cannabis oil is a rather useful mix of cannabinoids, developed to safeguard versus 21st century illness. Oil of cannabis in a kind of hobby APR consists of little amounts of CBD, stabilized by the existence of THC.

  4. Did you know these realities on CBD OIL and Full Spectrum CBD Hemp Oil? Cannabinoids are isolated from hemp using supercritical CO2 extraction. Thanks to modern-day innovation, the resulting option is tidy, devoid of heavy metals and unneeded waxes, naturally present in the plant, and the drawn liquid has a normal, oily consistency. CBD oil contains cannabidiol as a base ingredient and might consist of only trace amounts of tetrahydroxycannabidiol (THC). It is advised by doctors and pharmacists as an antioxidant and substance that blocks the action of proinflammatory cytokines (proteins), e.g. in Crohn’s disease or ulcerative intestinal tract. RSO oil has a low CBD content, while high THC. The synergistic (enhancing) action of CBD and THC relative to each other is utilized here. Both cannabinoids can do much more together than when used separately. Both marijuana oil type CBD and RSO also include other cannabinoids, such as cannabichromene (CBC) and cannabigerol (CBG). The trick is not, however, that CBD typically has a composition broadened to include flavones, flavonoids, terpenes, terpenoids, amino acids and omega acids. The distinction is primarily due to motives assisting mankind to utilize one or the other item. CBD medical cannabis oil is a rather useful blend of cannabinoids, developed to safeguard versus 21st century disease. It’s finest to use all of these compounds together, as nature created them and enclosed in cannabis inflorescences. Oil of marijuana in a kind of hobby APR contains percentages of CBD, balanced by the presence of THC. Makers concentrate on the synergistic result of one compound relative to the other, while abandoning the presence of CBC and CBG. Why such a decision? – Modern clinical research study shows that CBD + THC handle major autoimmune illness, while CBC or CBG show very little activity in the existence of both substances, much like flavonoids, flavones or terpenes, for that reason their content in the option seems to be unnecessary. In addition, the cannabis stress from which THC and CBD are obtained contain minimal quantities of other cannabinoids. RSO oil is entirely illegal in Poland, which is why it can not be acquired in any legally running shop on the marketplace. Obviously, there are a number of amateur approaches for getting it, however it’s great to know that compounds obtained synthetically in home labs doubt, untested, and the result unknown. The solvent for the production of home RSO is generally fuel, alcohol and even kerosene, which rather of treating, poison. Alcohols and their like hinder cannabinoids, therefore in reality, they do not bring anything brand-new to the medical world. Marijuana oil has currently marked a brand-new era in which man ceased to fear what is unknown, and started to rediscover what our forefathers had currently discovered and use the substantial capacity, at first glance, a little strange relationships, associated primarily with pathology. Medical cannabis, contrary to its name, does not indicate fermented female inflorescences and leaves including psychoactive compounds coiled in so-called “Joints”, however a beneficial oil without psychoactive THC. A basic individual, after taking dosages of medical cannabis and accomplishing the suitable state of cannabinoids in the blood, can delight in increased immunity, lowered susceptibility to cancer, delayed aging and reduced risk of stroke or heart attack. CBD oil consists of cannabidiol as a base active ingredient and may contain just trace quantities of tetrahydroxycannabidiol (THC). RSO oil has a low CBD material, while high THC. Both marijuana oil type CBD and RSO also contain other cannabinoids, such as cannabichromene (CBC) and cannabigerol (CBG). CBD medical marijuana oil is a rather helpful blend of cannabinoids, developed to safeguard against 21st century illness. Oil of marijuana in a kind of pastime APR consists of little quantities of CBD, balanced by the existence of THC.

  5. Did you understand these facts on CBD OIL and Full Spectrum CBD Hemp Oil? Cannabinoids are isolated from hemp using supercritical CO2 extraction. Thanks to modern-day technology, the resulting option is tidy, free of heavy metals and unnecessary waxes, naturally present in the plant, and the sucked liquid has a common, oily consistency. CBD oil contains cannabidiol as a base component and may include just trace amounts of tetrahydroxycannabidiol (THC). It is suggested by doctors and pharmacists as an antioxidant and compound that obstructs the action of proinflammatory cytokines (proteins), e.g. in Crohn’s illness or ulcerative intestine. RSO oil has a low CBD material, while high THC. The synergistic (enhancing) action of CBD and THC relative to each other is utilized here. Both cannabinoids can do much more together than when utilized separately. Both cannabis oil type CBD and RSO also contain other cannabinoids, such as cannabichromene (CBC) and cannabigerol (CBG). The trick is not, however, that CBD often has a composition broadened to consist of flavones, flavonoids, terpenes, terpenoids, amino acids and omega acids. The distinction is mainly due to motives guiding humanity to utilize one or the other product. CBD medical marijuana oil is a rather advantageous blend of cannabinoids, created to secure versus 21st century disease. It’s finest to utilize all of these substances together, as nature produced them and confined in marijuana inflorescences. It ends up that cannabidiol boosts the effects of cannabichromene (CBC) and cannabigerol (CBG), and flavones or flavonoids enhance the absorption of these substances. Omega-6 and omega-3 highly nourish the body and do not permit to alter, which accelerate the aging procedure of the organism and enhance the development of cancer. Oil of cannabis in a type of hobby APR contains small quantities of CBD, stabilized by the existence of THC. Makers focus on the synergistic result of one substance relative to the other, while abandoning the presence of CBC and CBG. Why such a decision? – Modern scientific research reveals that CBD + THC cope with major autoimmune illness, while CBC or CBG show very little activity in the presence of both substances, much like flavonoids, terpenes or flavones, therefore their content in the solution appears to be unnecessary. In addition, the marijuana pressure from which THC and CBD are obtained contain negligible quantities of other cannabinoids. RSO oil is entirely illegal in Poland, which is why it can not be acquired in any legally running store on the marketplace. Obviously, there are a variety of amateur approaches for obtaining it, however it’s good to understand that compounds gotten synthetically in home laboratories doubt, untried, and the impact unknown. The solvent for the production of home RSO is usually gasoline, alcohol and even kerosene, which rather of curing, toxin. Alcohols and their like hinder cannabinoids, therefore in truth, they do not bring anything new to the medical world. Marijuana oil has actually currently marked a new period in which man stopped to fear what is unknown, and started to rediscover what our ancestors had actually currently noticed and use the considerable potential, at very first glance, a little bizarre relationships, associated mainly with pathology. Medical marijuana, contrary to its name, does not imply fermented female inflorescences and leaves including psychoactive substances coiled in so-called “Joints”, but a helpful oil without psychedelic THC. A standard person, after taking dosages of medicinal marijuana and accomplishing the appropriate state of cannabinoids in the blood, can take pleasure in increased resistance, reduced vulnerability to cancer, delayed aging and minimized risk of stroke or heart attack. CBD oil includes cannabidiol as a base component and might include just trace quantities of tetrahydroxycannabidiol (THC). RSO oil has a low CBD material, while high THC. Both cannabis oil type CBD and RSO likewise contain other cannabinoids, such as cannabichromene (CBC) and cannabigerol (CBG). CBD medical marijuana oil is a rather beneficial mix of cannabinoids, designed to safeguard versus 21st century disease. Oil of cannabis in a kind of pastime APR consists of small quantities of CBD, stabilized by the existence of THC.

  6. Did you understand these facts on CBD OIL and Full Spectrum CBD Hemp Oil? Cannabinoids are separated from hemp using supercritical CO2 extraction. Thanks to contemporary technology, the resulting service is clean, devoid of heavy metals and unneeded waxes, naturally present in the plant, and the drawn liquid has a typical, oily consistency. CBD oil contains cannabidiol as a base active ingredient and might include only trace amounts of tetrahydroxycannabidiol (THC). Functions as a memory enhancer, improving concentration and coordination of movements, eliminating inflammation and persistent infections. It improves the conduction of stimuli in the course of autoimmune diseases (multiple sclerosis, amyotrophic sclerosis). It is recommended by medical professionals and pharmacists as an antioxidant and compound that blocks the action of proinflammatory cytokines (proteins), e.g. in Crohn’s disease or ulcerative intestinal tract. RSO oil has a low CBD material, while high THC. The synergistic (enhancing) action of CBD and THC relative to each other is used here. Both cannabinoids can do much more together than when used independently. Both marijuana oil type CBD and RSO also consist of other cannabinoids, such as cannabichromene (CBC) and cannabigerol (CBG). The trick is not, nevertheless, that CBD typically has actually a structure broadened to consist of flavones, flavonoids, terpenes, terpenoids, amino acids and omega acids. The difference is mostly due to motives directing humanity to use one or the other product. CBD medical marijuana oil is a rather useful blend of cannabinoids, created to secure against 21st century disease. It’s finest to utilize all of these compounds together, as nature produced them and enclosed in cannabis inflorescences. Oil of marijuana in a sort of hobby APR consists of percentages of CBD, stabilized by the presence of THC. Makers concentrate on the synergistic effect of one compound relative to the other, while deserting the existence of CBC and CBG. Why such a decision? – Modern scientific research study reveals that CBD + THC handle serious autoimmune diseases, while CBC or CBG reveal very little activity in the presence of both substances, much like flavones, terpenes or flavonoids, therefore their material in the solution seems to be unnecessary. In addition, the marijuana stress from which THC and CBD are obtained include negligible quantities of other cannabinoids. RSO oil is completely prohibited in Poland, which is why it can not be obtained in any lawfully running store on the market. Of course, there are a number of amateur methods for getting it, but it’s great to know that substances acquired synthetically in house laboratories are uncertain, untried, and the impact unknown. The solvent for the production of home RSO is generally gasoline, alcohol and even kerosene, which rather of curing, toxin. Alcohols and their like impair cannabinoids, and so in truth, they do not bring anything new to the medical world. Marijuana oil has currently marked a new era in which man ceased to fear what is unknown, and began to rediscover what our ancestors had already noticed and utilize the significant capacity, at very first glance, a little strange relationships, associated mainly with pathology. Medical marijuana, contrary to its name, does not suggest fermented female inflorescences and leaves consisting of psychoactive compounds coiled in so-called “Joints”, however a helpful oil without psychoactive THC. A standard individual, after taking doses of medical marijuana and achieving the proper state of cannabinoids in the blood, can take pleasure in increased immunity, decreased susceptibility to cancer, delayed aging and decreased risk of stroke or cardiovascular disease. CBD oil contains cannabidiol as a base ingredient and might contain only trace quantities of tetrahydroxycannabidiol (THC). RSO oil has a low CBD material, while high THC. Both cannabis oil type CBD and RSO also consist of other cannabinoids, such as cannabichromene (CBC) and cannabigerol (CBG). CBD medical cannabis oil is a rather helpful mix of cannabinoids, designed to secure against 21st century illness. Oil of marijuana in a kind of pastime APR contains little amounts of CBD, stabilized by the presence of THC.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*