Change for the Worse: The Assault on the 4th Amendment

“Meet the new boss, same as the old boss…”

The Who’s line is as true now as it was in 1971 and as true as the similar old French saying, “the more things change the more they stay the same.” The same idea is repeated again and again in folk wisdom from every culture, which suggests that it’s based on a shared element of human experience. Change is inevitable, but too often its results are only superficial.

In this case the deja vu we’d rather not be experiencing all over again comes from the Obama administration’s diligent efforts to outdo his much-reviled predecessor when it comes to shreedding our constitutional rights in the interest of national security. Like President Bush, President Obama seems intent on focusing his efforts on rendering the Fourth Amendment utterly meaningless. You know that amendment. It reads:

“The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.”

It’s the amendment that reminds government and other entities that we have an absolute right to privacy which they can’t just violate at a whim. It’s been under assault for years and eroded away more and more with each new governmental initiative to protect us from the latest bogeyman or from ourselves. The War on Drugs with its asset seizures and warrantless searches has been wearing away at our rights for more than 30 years, but nothing has done more harm than the War on Terror which took the cold-war era Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978 and expanded it into a blanket authorization to execute thousands of warrantless wiretaps against US citizens, often with very little justification and virtually no accountability.

FISA was already blatantly in violation of the 4th Amendment before the Bush administration got hold of it. They took the blanket authorization for unlimited wiretapping which was implied in the legislation and ran with it, making it the justification for datamining and automated content scanning of telecommunications completely outside the scope of the technology available when FISA was written, but arguably authorized under the overly broad language of the law. When challenged, they went to the compliant congress and got amendments to the FISA Act in 2008 which protected many of their practices and reduced the level of accountability in the act still further. The ACLU has launched a lawsuit over the constitutionality of the FISA Amendments Act of 2008, but to date it remains in force, giving unprecedented power to the federal government to basically scan and listen to any telecommunications with no prior approval.

Although you might think that President Obama, riding in on his white horse last November, might be here to save us from the Bush administration’s assault on our rights, it turns out that when it comes to warrantless surveillance, they’re enthusiastic supporters of the program and are even willing to take the idea of complete lack of accountability for violating our privacy to a higher level. In a motion to dismiss the case Jewel vs. NSA the Obama Justice Department they reiterated the Bush-era argument that cases against FISA cannot even be brought because they “would cause exceptionally grave harm to national security.” Going even further than Bush did, they also argue that the idea of ‘sovereign immunity’ makes the Department of Justice completely immune from any prosecution for violating the rights of citizens. Not only do we not have the protection of due process under the 4th Amendment, but now we have no standing to sue and even if we do get a case in court the government is immune from any prosecution. As the Electronic Frontier Foundation interprets it, “Essentially, the Obama Adminstration has claimed that the government cannot be held accountable for illegal surveillance under any federal statutes.” So we might as well lie back and take whatever they want to do to us, because those 4th Amendment rights are just gone forever.

This is a strange and ironic change from candidate Obama who said he wanted more transparency in government, but perhaps even more ominous is the latest move from the administration to take complete control of the internet under the newly proposed Cybersecurity Act of 2009 which follows an earlier act which would establish a “Cybersecurity Czar” to oversee internet security. This bill will give the president the ability to “declare a cybersecurity emergency” and shut down or limit internet traffic at any time “in the interest of national security,” a situation whose parameters are left undefined. What’s worse, it gives the Secretary of Commerce “access to all relevant data concerning (critical) networks without regard to any provision of law, regulation, rule, or policy restricting such access.” This is another attack on the 4th Amendment, giving completely unaccountable federal officials total access to internet communications without any safeguards of the rights and privacy of citizens. There’s no requirement for a warrant, no need for probable cause, no liability for any harm done and not even any requirement for reporting or limitations on how these powers can be exercises.

This proposed act runs directly counter to the protections provided in the 4th Amendment and also the Electronic Communications Privacy Act which was passed in the 1980s to reaffirm that privacy rights applied to internet communications. The act is supported by powerful congressional Democrats and by the Obama administration, so it stands a reasonably good chance of passing, and it’s just the first step in a comprehensive strategy to expand government control over the internet and what goes on there. The good news is that unlike FISA and its recent amendments, this bill has not yet passed into law and it’s possible that with enough public opposition it might be altered to include safeguards for the privacy rights of citizens while still addressing legitimate national security needs.

With FISA and the expansion of FISA under the Bush administration we saw too much of our liberty legislated away in the name of national security. It is now clear that the Obama administration wants to continue and expand on that trend. It has never seemed more believable that the future of universal surveillance and the elimination of personal privacy envisioned in George Orwell’s 1984 might become a reality. The 4th Amendment was a powerful and definitive statement on privacy rights, but as things stand today it is almost as if it never existed. It is not being observed or enforced and seems to mean nothing to the bureaucrats of the security establishment or the current administration.

We may very well need protection from terrorists and malicious hackers and cyberwarfare, but safety from those threats has much less value if we lose our basic freedoms in the process. It is fundamentally wrong to treat all citizens as criminals to catch the real criminals or to take away everyone’s privacy to expose hidden enemies. The emergence of new technology and new mediums of communication does not make our old-fashioned rights obsolete. We just have to find new ways to preserve and protect those rights within the new worlds which technology has opened up for us. As we go forward, the preservation of our rights and protection of citizens from government as well as external threats, must be our highest priority.


About Dave 536 Articles
Dave Nalle has worked as a magazine editor, a freelance writer, a capitol hill staffer, a game designer and taught college history for many years. He now designs fonts for a living and lives with his family in a small town just outside Austin where he is ex-president of the local Lions Club. He is on the board of the Republican Liberty Caucus and Politics Editor of Blogcritics Magazine. You can find his writings about fonts, art and graphic design at The Scriptorium. He also runs a conspiracy debunking site at


  1. I loved as much as you will receive carried out right here.
    The sketch is attractive, your authored material stylish.
    nonetheless, you command get got an nervousness over that you wish
    be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come more
    formerly again as exactly the same nearly very often inside case you shield this hike.

  2. The first crucial action will be to cautiously look in the material you must add
    to your essay. Thatüfs right, weüfre likely to party to
    the next couple weeks, so rev up the cheer. pointed ( This is why an SEO campaign alone won’t necessarily change your
    company, or help to develop it. Avoiding the temptation to ‘rush’ the writing process to publish
    as much as time allows now lets you concentrate on other areas of the business.

  3. When the writers have selected the subject, they ought to ensure the research in regards to the topic.
    Also, you’ll find some students who donüft like essay writing since they are not properly equipped on how to utilize
    language well. tries ( A well
    calm as well as relaxed mental abilities are crucial to the purpose of creative writing.

    Punctuation has had a very bad time in the last forty years approximately but I believe it
    really is about to undergo a revival.

  4. This is essential because your paper and hard work will all be in vain should your professor will quickly realize
    mistakes inside your paper. So when interviewing potential ghost writers, ensure you request samples
    which might be written inside style you’re after. diz ( Return to
    ‘Middle School lesson plan: SPAM and Stairstep Thinking’.
    7) Never let your character eat an apple when he could be eating fried Cheerios.

  5. chromium polynicotinate dangers

    Bring in a sense of urgency using words which have more weight.

    The picture inside your mind really needs to become moved to that of your reader.
    mill,, atkins diet phase 1 agreed
    that expressing the literacy proficiencies of adults in class-based terms
    or grade-level scores is inappropriate. Naturally workshops is going to be agreed upon the concept of
    assorted time schedules and writers can make the best period based
    on the utility.

  6. To save this from happening within the future, simply place a number of that rubberized mesh (the kind
    of that you use to line your cabinet shelves) right under the sofa
    cushions. Additional amenities include complementary beverage, easy-to-set noisy alarms radio and sofa bed and more.

    One can be able to “talk down” the salesperson,
    printing out a similar online deal and seeing when they is willing to competitive price a sectional sofa.

    Leather looks elegant and is also durable
    that makes it better than all one other sofas available out there.
    Sofa sleeper manufacturers often often focus more around the making of
    your Quality Sofa; the bed is basically an afterthought.

    Do not merely write a vague title that does not relate for the
    rest with the article. Any good ghost writer has previous
    customers willing to talk for you for 15 minutes.
    might,, sleeper
    sofa twin size Essay writing services tend to be offered at
    a reasonable price. ? Each essay answer should start with a quick thesis statement that summarizes the way to go.

  7. The wheel looks like something off of an old steam boat
    which is what the motor spins so that you can evacuate
    the dirty water from a machine. With no Agitator, you’ll be able
    to wash bulkier items for example sleeping bag, pillows etc.

    One of my personal favorite features on this Whirlpool WFW915DWW Washer is the Tumble – Fresh Cycle.
    There really are a lot of people with this world but at 300,000 people a clip it had been only a
    couple of time before we ran away from humans to at the mercy of Twitter.

    Concentrate on answering the “whys” behind the events
    within your story. A good command of the English language will go
    an extended way to write essay papers that your particular teachers will appreciate.
    Whirlpool cabrio reviews 2012 greater ( Each material presents different way
    with words, writing structure and writing format. What he doesn’t know is there’s a gunman waiting for

  8. To take a look yourself, you are able to reach underneath the
    front of all sofas and glance at the front with the frame.
    Motion – Craft also provides you a range of incline
    sofas and motorized recliner sofas for your comfort with a simple operating mechanism.
    Since you help growing rubber trees it becomes an eco friendly exercise when you acquire these sleeper sofa mattresses.

    Moreover, new inner spring mattresses can be obtained for futons so that you are able to expand it right into a much more comfort
    in a very bed than a sofa can provide. There are some luxury sofas who
    have inbuilt storage space, finish tables, adjustable head and footrests,
    and cup holders.

    Just remember not to copy their information; instead,
    use it inspiration. You perfected it every way you’ll be
    able to without the need to compromise your original ideas to greatly.
    Sleeper sofa overstock corresponding ( The objective of
    your order letter is always to give appropriate instructions towards the vendor to meet
    any order. Keep this planned, everything you’re posting and every article which you are doing.

  9. rca to hdmi converter walmart

    You should be sure of what you’re writing and the way you’re writing it.
    Provide specific details whiling structuring one main idea in a single
    paragraph. general [] rca to hdmi converter Order letters, also known as a PO (purchase order) letter, begins
    the paper track of a specific purchase. A vague or nonexistent wrote a write-up aims to waste their some time to energy.

  10. bed rail for elderly

    The key to writing a good paper is organization and making clear points.
    How could I ever believe in the people if they had moveable birthdays.
    Plastic truck bed rail caps greatest ( Once you obtain the hang of it it is possible to crank out a 400 word article in 10 or 15 minutes.
    The computer is logical, but is just not able to
    apply good sense to wording.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.